After Jonathan, Andrew, and Warren accidentally kill Warren's ex-girlfriend Katrina, they set Buffy up to make her believe it was she who killed the girl.
Quest roles:
Danny Strong(Jonathan Levinson), Adam Busch(Warren Mears), Tom Lenk(Andrew Wells), Amber Benson(Tara Maclay), Amelinda Embry(Katrina Silber), Marion Calvert(Gina), Bernard Addison(Cop), Eric Prescott(Cop), Armand Reiser(Desk Sergeant)