When Joe asks Peter to be the godfather to his daughter, Peter commits to his mistaken interpretation of the role so much that he becomes a real gangster.
Quest roles:
John Viener(Police Chief (uncredited) (archive footage) (voice)), Chris Parnell(Doug (voice)), Mike Desilets(Giant Crab (voice)), Ralph Garman(Various (uncredited) (archive footage) (voice)), Josh Robert Thompson(Sean Hannity (voice)), Dee Bradley Baker(Miss Tiggywinkles (voice)), Chris Cox(Kindergartener (voice)), Liam McIntyre(Isaac (voice)), Carlos Alazraqui(Cuban Man (voice)), John Colella(Don Amnesia (voice)), Rick Dees(Peter as Rick Dees (voice)), Damien Fahey(Matt (voice)), Ginger Gonzaga(Tammy (voice)), Luke Lowe(Trick-or-Treater (voice)), Amari McCoy(Little Girl (voice)), Alfred Molina(Chris' Neighbor (voice)), Danny Smith(Self), Maggie Lowe(First Grader (voice))