When Martha Brailsford goes out sailing in Salem, Massachusetts, and doesn't return, her friends and family immediately suspect that something terrible has happened.
Quest roles:
Sarafina King(Martha Brailsford / Muriel (twin sister)), Jason MacDonald(Tom Maimoni), Lindsay Abernathy(Rosemary), Ashlee Heath(Patti Maimoni), Levi Burdick(Brian Brailsford), Jesse Malinowski(Hooper Goodwin), Marty Stonerock(Laurie Cabot (Salem Psychic)), Allen O'Reilly(Harbor Master), Whit Davies(Captain Finn), Margaret Press(Self - Author, "A Scream on the Water"), Dorian Santiago(Det. Sgt. Conrad Prosniewski), Casie Bryant(Maggie (Neighbor)), James Swendsen(Sgt. Sullivan), Lee Buechele(Caretaker), Brandon Wood(Ben (teenager)), David Vann